7 Guardian Mistakes Parents Make
The Guardian Gap: 7 Heartbreaking Mistakes Parents Make—And How to Get It Right
As parents, we work tirelessly to protect our children—from choosing the safest car seats to finding the best schools and preparing healthy meals. But many loving, responsible parents unknowingly leave their children vulnerable when it comes to the most critical protection of all: what happens if you’re no longer there to care for them. Naming guardians isn’t just about filling in a blank on a will—it’s about ensuring that, no matter what life brings, your children are raised with love, stability, and the values that matter most to you. Sadly, small mistakes in guardianship planning can have devastating consequences. In this article, we’ll walk through seven of the most common mistakes parents make—and show you how to avoid them, giving your family true peace of mind.
A Moment of Clarity
It was a beautiful Saturday afternoon at the soccer field. Emma and her husband were cheering for their six-year-old when a friend casually mentioned meeting with an estate planning attorney. “We just finished our guardian paperwork,” she said. Emma froze. “Wait… we’ve never done that,” she whispered. “What would happen to Ava if something happened to us on the way home?”
That moment of realization hits many parents hard.
Who Will Raise Your Children If You Die?
You’ve researched the safest car seats, picked the right preschool, and stocked up on organic snacks—but have you made sure your children would be raised by the people you trust most, in the way you want, if something unexpected happened?
As an estate planning attorney in Garner, North Carolina, I’ve helped many families put legal safeguards in place for their children. And I can tell you this: love isn’t enough. Without the proper documents and thoughtful planning, your children could end up in the care of someone you never would’ve chosen—or even temporarily placed in foster care.
Unfortunately, many well-intentioned parents make avoidable mistakes when it comes to naming legal guardians. Below are the most common ones I see—and how you can do it differently.
Mistake #1: Thinking a Will Is Enough
Many parents breathe a sigh of relief after naming guardians in their will. “We’ve taken care of it,” they think. But the truth is: a will only takes effect after you’ve passed away—and only after it’s been through probate.
What happens if you’re seriously injured or incapacitated? The will doesn’t help. In the absence of specific legal documents addressing incapacity or temporary care, your children could be placed into protective custody.
A local client came to me after her sister was temporarily hospitalized. Despite loving grandparents being available, her children were placed with strangers overnight simply because no emergency guardianship plan existed.
The solution: In addition to a will, create a legal plan that covers incapacity and short-term emergencies. This ensures your children are never in the custody of the state—even for a few hours.
Mistake #2: Failing to Plan for Short-Term Emergencies
Let’s say you and your spouse are in a car accident while out to dinner. Your babysitter calls 911. First responders arrive. But, they can’t legally leave your kids with the sitter or neighbors. With no documentation authorizing emergency caregivers, your children may be taken into state custody, even if it’s only overnight.
It’s a nightmare scenario—and one that plays out more often than most people realize. Your kids will already be upset that you are not home. Would you want them to be even more traumatized if they need to be placed with strangers? Or, would you rather have them cared for by people you know, like and trust?
I’ve helped clients build what I call a Complete Family Security Plan that includes short-term guardian designations, wallet cards for first responders, and caregiver instructions to prevent this exact situation.
These aren’t just legal documents—they’re the difference between your child going home with Grandma or going to foster care.
Mistake #3: Not Naming Backups
Life is unpredictable. What if your first-choice guardian can’t serve due to illness, travel, or a change in circumstances? When it comes to protecting your children, having a "Plan A" simply isn't enough. Life rarely unfolds in a straight line—and your first-choice guardian may not always be available when you need them most.
Imagine this: you've carefully selected your best friend to raise your children if something happens to you. But what if, when the time comes, she's moved across the country? Or she's facing her own personal crisis—like a serious illness or financial hardship—and isn't able to take on the responsibility?
Without a backup guardian legally named, the court would be forced to step in and make a decision based on their judgment, not yours. In that moment of crisis, when your children need familiarity, stability, and love the most, they could instead face uncertainty and disruption.
I’ve seen families caught off guard by this. One client, who had named only her sister as guardian, never imagined her sister would later face a serious health condition making her unable to serve. Thankfully, we had taken the extra step to list backup guardians, ensuring that her children would still be raised within the family, by people who knew and loved them.
When it comes to guardianship, think in layers—not lines. Your child deserves a safety net, not just a single option.
Best practice is to name at least two, and ideally three, trusted backups in descending order of preference. Choose individuals or couples who:
Share your values
Have a strong relationship with your children
Would be willing and able to step in if needed
Understand your parenting philosophy and lifestyle choices
And just as importantly—talk to your backups. Make sure they understand your wishes and are willing to accept the responsibility if ever called upon.
Building out a full guardianship plan isn’t being pessimistic—it’s being prepared. It's one of the greatest acts of love you can give your children: the gift of uninterrupted care, no matter what twists life may bring.
Mistake #4: Choosing Guardians Based on Finances Alone
It’s natural to want your children raised by someone financially secure. But money isn’t everything—especially when it comes to love, values, and emotional connection.
One couple I worked with initially wanted to name the husband’s brother, a successful business owner, as guardian. But during our discussion, they realized he was rarely around, had no relationship with the kids, and didn’t share their parenting philosophy.
We then started talking about other potential family members who might be better suited to serve as guardians. We talked about how you can have two types of guardians named - one who cares for the children and one who oversees the children’s finances.
We structured such a plan. They named the wife’s sister, who was warm, engaged, and closely aligned with their values as the guardian. They then named the husband’s brother as trustee to manage the children’s funds. That way, the kids were raised in love and the finances were responsibly handled. A win win situation for everyone.
Mistake #5: Assuming Godparents Are Legal Guardians
For many families, choosing godparents is a cherished tradition—an emotional commitment celebrated with ceremony, promises, and even heartfelt letters. It’s an act of trust: “If something happens to us, we want you to be there.”
But here’s the difficult truth: being named a godparent holds no legal authority in the eyes of the law.
Even if everyone "knows" who you would want to step in, the court does not honor verbal promises, social expectations, or religious ceremonies. Only legally executed documents—signed, witnessed, and properly drafted—can ensure your chosen godparent can act as your child’s guardian.
I once worked with a family who thought they had everything covered. Their best friends were named godparents during a beautiful baptism ceremony. Everyone knew the plan—except when tragedy struck, the court couldn’t legally recognize the godparents without formal documentation. After weeks of painful proceedings, custody was awarded to a distant relative who had no close relationship with the children—simply because the legal paperwork wasn’t in place.
It was heartbreaking—and completely avoidable.
If your intent is for your child's godparents to raise your children if something happens to you, you must take the extra step of formally naming them as legal guardians in properly executed estate planning documents. This simple but critical action can prevent family conflict, court battles, and—most importantly—protect your child’s stability and emotional wellbeing during a traumatic time.
Legal planning doesn’t erase your beautiful traditions. It honors them—and ensures they’re respected when it matters most.Mistake #6: Not Updating Your Plan
People change. Relationships shift. Guardians you chose when your child was a toddler may not be the best fit now.
I had a client whose original guardian choice had since gone through a contentious divorce and moved to another state. They hadn’t spoken in over a year. Had they not updated their plan, that individual would still have been legally responsible for their child if something happened.
Review your plan every 2–3 years, or after any major life event (like a move, divorce, or birth). Make sure it still reflects your values—and your child’s best interests.
Mistake #7: Not Communicating Your Wishes
Naming the right guardians is critical—but without sharing your hopes, values, and expectations, even the most loving guardian can be left navigating uncharted waters.
Imagine your child’s guardian standing in your living room after a tragedy—wondering:
Would you want your child raised in a particular faith?
Should they attend public school, private school, or be homeschooled?
How would you want milestones celebrated?
What bedtime routines, family traditions, or holiday rituals were important to you?
How would you want discipline and screen time handled?
Without your voice guiding them, even the best guardians can feel lost—and your child can lose more than just their parents; they can lose the small, meaningful pieces of family life that made them feel safe and loved.
I once counseled a guardian who became responsible for her two young nieces after a sudden accident. While she adored the girls, she was overwhelmed with decisions: where they should live, how their schedules should be maintained, whether they should remain in the same extracurricular activities. “I just wish my sister had left me something to follow,” she told me through tears.
The solution? Go beyond legal documents. Leave a written “letter of intent” or “legacy letter” that outlines your values, hopes, and specific wishes for your children's upbringing. It doesn’t have to be formal or complicated—it simply needs to exist.
Some things you may want to share:
Your educational philosophy
Religious or cultural practices important to you
Daily routines or traditions you want honored
Hobbies, interests, or skills you hoped your children would develop
The kind of people you hoped they would grow up to be
This letter becomes a powerful bridge between you and your children’s future—a way to parent them even if you’re not physically present. It reassures the guardian, guides major decisions, and keeps your child emotionally grounded.
Remember: A legal guardianship plan protects your child’s physical safety.
A legacy letter protects their emotional foundation.
Both are equally priceless.
What a Complete Family Security Plan Looks Like
At my firm, we help parents create a comprehensive plan that includes:
Legally named short-term and long-term guardians
Emergency caregiver instructions
Medical authorizations for minor children
Letters of intention and value-based parenting guidance
Instructions for schools, babysitters, and neighbors
Optional separation of guardianship and financial trusteeship
It’s about more than avoiding legal risk. It’s about giving your child the greatest gift of all: certainty, love, and continuity—no matter what life brings.
Why This Matters (Especially in North Carolina)
In North Carolina, if no guardian is named, the court decides who will raise your child. That process can be long, public, and emotionally exhausting. And even well-meaning judges can make decisions that don’t reflect your wishes.
As a local estate planning attorney serving families in Garner and across the Triangle, I help parents avoid this painful uncertainty. Together, we create legally sound, heart-centered plans to protect what matters most: your children.
Final Thought: The Peace You Deserve
Picture this: You’re tucking your children in at night, and for the first time in months, you feel true peace.
Because if something happens tomorrow—your children will be cared for by the people you chose, in the way you believe in. No court battles. No questions. No chaos.
Just love. Just clarity. Just the plan you made to protect them.
Ready to Create Your Plan?
Let’s talk. I offer a free 15-minute discovery call where we’ll review your goals, answer your questions, and take the first step together.
To schedule your free Discovery Call, click the below button:
